The New York Lifestyle in Belize
Living abroad offers a unique adventure, you experience new cultures and sights, yet sometimes you miss familiar comforts from home. This is especially true for expats, they often crave tastes and experiences from their past lives. Belize is a tropical paradise. But even here you can find little pieces of home, and that’s the “same same but different” feeling.
It’s natural to want those familiar tastes. Even in a sunny place like Belize, those cravings can hit hard. For those who once called New York home, certain things are truly missed. Think of a classic deli sandwich or a perfect morning bagel. Luckily, you don’t have to go without. Ambergris Caye, Belize has some spots that really bring back those New York vibes.
This overview will take you to three special places in San Pedro, Belize. These spots offer satisfying tastes and experiences. They capture that New York essence. You’ll discover where to get a great sandwich, a perfect bagel with coffee, and a lively public space that shares the same name to one of our city favorites. Get ready to find your New York fix right here in Belize.
Read more like this » Things to do with your Family in Belize «
-
Indulge in Authentic Deli Delights at Frenchy’s

A Taste of NYC Heroes
New Yorkers have specific ideas about delis. They think of massive sandwiches, often called heroes or subs, that you get loaded with meats and cheeses. In Belize, the deli scene is a bit different. You might find more local options like meat pies or fry jacks. It’s a shift from the typical New York deli experience.
But Frenchy’s is changing that. This place is serving up some seriously substantial sandwiches. It’s a welcome sight for anyone missing that New York deli portion. Their brand new deli, still in its early days, is already making waves. It’s a place where you can get that big, satisfying sandwich you’ve been longing for.
Mortadella & Mozzarella Perfection

Rachel tried the mortadella and mozzarella sandwich at Frenchy’s. It was absolutely delicious. And the best part? It was huge! They had to take half of it to go. If you’re looking for a real New York-style deli sandwich, Frenchy’s is the spot.
If you are craving a francier meal, Frenchy’s is also open for dinner.
-
Savor Classic Bagels and Fresh Coffee
Brooklyn Brothers: Your Bagel Destination
New York is famous for its bagels. Thankfully, Brooklyn Brothers makes fresh bagels regularly. You can even find their bagels in their brick and mortar, and even in some of the local supermarkets. It’s a great way to get that essential New York breakfast.
Caye Roasting: The Perfect Coffee Pairing
What’s a bagel without coffee? Right next door to Brooklyn Brothers is Caye Roasting. They serve up fresh cups of coffee with the beans being roasted right there on site. This means your coffee is always super fresh. It’s the perfect partner for your Brooklyn Brothers bagel.
-
Experience the Heartbeat of San Pedro’s Central Park

Central Park: A Familiar Gathering Place
When feeling nostalgic, head to San Pedro’s Central Park. It’s not the same as New York’s famous park, but it can serve a similar purpose. It’s the central gathering spot in downtown San Pedro. You’ll find people relaxing and spending time together.
Evening Ambiance and Community Events
In the evenings, Central Park comes alive. Families gather here to unwind. You’ll find food stalls offering tasty meals. Sometimes, artisan markets pop up. Other community events also happen in this lively space. It’s located on Front Street, right in the heart of downtown San Pedro.
Read more like this » Healthcare in Belize «
-
Discovering Slices of New York Life in Belize

Embracing the “Same Same But Different” Philosophy
These spots in San Pedro truly capture that “same same but different” spirit. Frenchy’s deli gives you that New York sandwich experience. Brooklyn Brothers and Caye Roasting offer classic bagel and coffee pairings. Central Park provides a community hub like its NYC namesake. They show how you can find familiar comforts with a local twist.
Actionable Tips for Expats and Visitors
If you’re new to Belize or missing home, seek out these places. They offer a taste of what you might be missing. Even small comforts can make a big difference when living abroad. Exploring these local gems can help you feel more at home. It’s about finding those connections to your past life.

-
Making Belize Your Home: Resources for Relocation
Expert Team Assistance for Your Move
Are you thinking about moving to Belize? It’s a big decision, but you don’t have to do it alone. Our team is here to help. We have over a decade of experience with people relocating to Belize. We want to make your move as smooth as possible.
Complimentary Resources for a Smooth Transition
We offer free resources to help you, including a “Moving to Belize Guide”. It covers important information for your transition. You can email us at info@lunarealtybelize.com for a copy.
Conclusion
In San Pedro, Belize, you can find echoes of New York life. Frenchy’s Deli satisfies your craving for a hearty sandwich. Brooklyn Brothers and Caye Roasting deliver excellent bagels and fresh coffee. San Pedro’s Central Park offers a vibrant community space. These places embody the “same same but different” essence.
Belize is a beautiful place to live. You can enjoy its paradise while still finding familiar comforts. Experiencing these spots will show you that. If you’re considering Belize for your new home, reach out to us. We’re ready to help you make the move. Come and see why Belize is paradise.
Join the video to check out the Top 3 Places in Belize that Remind You of New York—you won’t believe the similarities!
🏝️ Ready to explore paradise?
Subscribe to our channel @lunarealtybelize for exclusive Belize real estate property tours, insider tips, and answers to all your Belize property questions.

